The purple is a lovely color, it goes on smoothly, although it doesn't smudge as well as I'd like. The liner held up well all day.

Goes on smooth, and lasts long. smudged a little after a while. The color was nice. Might even try the other colors :)

Great great eyeliner. It gave a really nice, smooth, and consistently dark line. It ran out a bit quickly, but that might just have something to say about how much I used it! I really liked the product.

Although I dont usually purchase black eyeliners due to my skin color, I liked this product. It's smooth and durable.

I haven't worn eyeliner since Junior High so this was a homecoming for me. Nice texture and ease in application, but for me the product was gone by the end of the day. My eyes kept tearing (allergies) so that might be the reason why. I wore this to a wedding this weekend and it seemed to stay on till late in the PM. I got the sample of black which is great. I like the way it was smudge-able so I could soften the look. Nice product but I'm not crazy about it being made in Taiwan. But the price is right, and I just saw that you have a 4 color set. I will read more reviews and probably purchase this again in full size for myself!

I received this in my May box and was excited to try it--I received the black colored eyeliner. Normally the darkest I go with eyeliner is either a dark grey or black brown (I am pretty fair skinned with blue eyes). I usually do pretty traditional makeup, nothing too heavy or exciting.

I tightlined with this on my upper lashes--was WAY too dark for me to use on the bottom and overall I was pretty happy with the results. It flows nicely, has good color and didn't irritate my eyes--all positives.

My only complaint is that by the end of the day, I looked a little more 'dramatic' than I had hoped due to a great amount of this moving from my upper lash line to my waterline on the bottom (and below my lash line and in the corner of my eye....basically all over. If I hadn't been checking in the mirror a few times over the course of the day and had a q-tip at the ready, I would have been a mess). I didn't cry, wasn't in particularly warm weather and actually have pretty dry eyes, so I'm kind of underwhelmed at the staying power of this. It was nice, glad I got it as a sample, but I think I'll be sticking to the pencil liners that I normally use.

I work long days and this eyeliner lives up to the task. Goes on smooth and lasts all day without smearing, smudging or a need for reapplication.

This is just pretty basic eyeliner. Im more of a fan of liquid eyeliner but this is pretty good for a pencil.

After using this product for two days, I realized how terribly it runs and bleeds just after a normal day of wear! And it is not possible to remove it with normal face wash but rather you have to use eye makeup remover.

Not in love with it, but a good product. Goes on smooth. Doesn't last long