I'm surprised this has such high reviews. It's just ok. Recently, I've been wearing BENEFIT COSMETICS
They're Real! Mascara. While it's not a waterproof mascara, it can be tough to remove. My regular face wash wasn't cutting it, so I ordered this hoping it would make the task easier. It's not very effective. The formula is gentle, but I ended up having to keep going over the same area several times, and it still didn't take everything off. The extra rubbing irritated my eyes. Being 36, I try to be careful not to tug too much and cause pre-mature aging, especially around the eye area. Disappointed in this product. Within the same order, I also ordered LA FRESH® Waterproof Makeup Remover (Individual Packets). They are awesome and took everything off right away without irritation or extra tugging at the eye area. I think most eye make is going to require something with some oils to release the makeup from the skin. I would not recommend this product.
I bought this (separate from Birchbox) and have fallen in love. It's super clean feeling ! I don't wear a ton of makeup but when I do, this stuff gets it off that night... or the next morning.
Klorane Soothing makeup remover with cornflower water
This is a really good sensitive eye makeup remover. Don't use too much a little goes a long way, too much gets into your eyes and burns a bit.
This is an amazing makeup remover
I love this product. It removes all of the makeup I seem to leave on even after washing my face. It never burns my eyes or feels harsh in anyway. I love the very light fragrance and I will definitely purchase it again when I am out. Of all the makeup removers I have this does the best job.
Nice and not oily! This makeup remover is great to use at night or to touch up a mistake without leaving any residue to make your eye makeup slide off!
light and clean
This is a nice product. I love that it's not oily!! I still find the need to use my face wash to remove some of my eye makeup even after using this though. But that's okay bc it does feel light and clean after each use.
I use a cotton ball to remove my makeup with this remover. My skin feels fresh and clean after and I don't have to rinse it away. A new favorite.
Nice and Gentle
This makeup remover cleared everything off my face, and didn't leave behind an oily residue like some removers do. I DO choose to splash my face with water after using the product, but more out of habit than anything else.
Takes off all my makeup
Great makeup remover, especially for taking off all of my eye makeup easily although I'll use it all over my face as well before washing with a cleanser. It's gentle on my eyes, no stinging or irritation. My only complaint is that the scent is a little different, not unpleasant, but definitely noticeable to me.
very gentle eye makeup remover. good for most eye makeup, although may need an extra swipe or two for more resistant eye makeup (anything too creamy, like a kohl eyeliner).