I really wanted a good selection of black/gray shadow to wear with smoky liner. This is an ok quad, but not my favorite. It's more sparkly than the photo appears, and also more gray than black that what the name says.
I find if I don't use a primer this gets very creased in my lid throughout the day and I look like I have a black eye. If you use a primer though I recommend letting it dry FULLY before applying this shadow. I put it on while my primer was the littlest bit tacky, and this shadow gunked up and then wouldn't come off. I will still use it, but it's not exactly what I expected.
This eyeshadow goes on so smooth and clean. It looks brilliant and i can wear it anywhere and it lasts all day.
I used this over primer and it seemed to last pretty well throughout the day. Minimal fallout. However, I was slightly bummed that the grey shades came out looking more purplish grey than grey to black on me. I may try the black magic shade to get the coloring I desire. Overall I would buy again. Pigment is on the medium side but worked well for building color and blended smoothly.