Order Standard by 2 p.m. ET 12/19 for 12/24 delivery. Standard $25+ orders ship free
Create a free account to check out faster, store multiple shipping addresses, view and track your orders in your account, and much more.
Please enter your password to continue.
I absolutly love this eyeliner. It glides on smoothly and stays all day. Love all the colors also!
I received the sailor blue and loved it so much I bought the duo. I love liner but hate how most smear and end up in the crease of your eye. This one goes on smoothly and stays where you apply it. So happy to have found them!
The Caribbean Sea is such a pretty color! It's not too dark, and it really stays on well. It doesn't cake, and it looks lovely!
I really like the Mally eyeliners and this is a great deal since you get two that work well together.
They stay on well and go on easily.
I received the sailor (navy blue) shade in my monthly birchbox. It was extremely impressed with its staying power and how beautiful the color looked (five-star quality). I was so happy with the product I purchased the duo with midnight black and royal plum. The midnight black was pretty good, decent staying power but not as impressive as sailor (four-star quality) but the royal plum barely stayed for very long, if it stayed on at all (2-star quality). All-in-all I highly recommend sailor and would stay away from the remaining shades.
These eyeliners go on smooth and stay on all day. The do not smudge as bad as most liners. They are not "smudge free" as they claim but better than most.
I sampled the Sailor Blue one in my box awhile back and decided that I had to have more! So I opted for the duo vs. just one. (More bang for your buck ya know?!) They go on very smoothly, and are easy to work with. Haven't had a problem with the color smudging or rubbing off and I'm constantly rubbing my eyes. Will definitely be buying again!
They glide on smoothly, and I didn't have a problem with the color smudging or coming off. I just ran out and will be buying again! The smoothness of them is probably my favorite part!
I sampled the Sailor blue eyeliner and was very pleased with how it complimented my brown eyes. However, after a few hours at work I noticed a lot of smudging. I am a fan of the color, but will probably stick with products that don't smudge.