Order 2nd Day on full-size orders by 11:59 p.m. ET 12/20 for 12/24 delivery. Details
Create a free account to check out faster, store multiple shipping addresses, view and track your orders in your account, and much more.
Please enter your password to continue.
When I opened my box to discover the 'sailor' blue eye liner, I thought I would never use it. However, one night I got brave and wore it to a party and LOTS of people commented on how great my eyes looked. And what a treat to get a full size sample. I loved it so much that I purchased the 'midight' as well!
Luck Penny is absolutely gorgeous, goes on nice and smooth and you don't have to worry about smudging! Will rebuy!
I never do reviews unless its an amazing product ! I got this as one of my sample packs in the mail yesterday and tried it this morning for work..it goes on so good! its the prettttyiest color navy blue and I am in loveeee..deff need to buy it when I run out!
I instantly fell in love with the Mally Beauty Evercolor Eye liner and pretty much the only reason I didn't give it a 5 stars was I couldn't seem to get it resharpened with any of the sharpeners I had handy. Its definitely a perfect stocking stuffer for the Holidays!
This is my new favorite eye liner. I was using a high end product before for years and this eyeliner is smoother and has the same lasting quality as the designer eye liner I was using before. I received a blue color and it looked nice with my fair complexion. I don't use an eye makeup remover and so a little bit of the eyeliner would stay put overnight, which I kind of like! It wouldn't rub off onto my skin or my pillow. It also has a slight sheen to it, but not too much. More of a youthful glow. Go for it!
This eyeliner goes on nice and smooth, but the color wasn't right for me. I have olive skin, dark hair, and dark eyes, and I received the blue color in my box. Wish I would have received black!
It stays on once you put it one, but I really wish that this eye liner stayed a bit firmer. I live in a warm climate and the point loses its sharpness and also sometimes melts a bit. Once you apply though, the color is very nice and it does stay on after application.
I had gotten away from stand-out eye liners, but this one won me over. It goes on so easily, so even. And the navy color was a hit! I'd recommend this to anyone!
Great eyeliner - love the sailor blue color, and it's definitely waterproof! Takes some effort to get off at night.
I received this in Sailor in my monthly Birchbox. It goes on so smooth and lasts ALL day! I just HAD to purchase it in Midnight as well. Great product and would recommend to anyone!