My only complaint for this product is the price point (-1 star). Functionally, it works great to make long yet natural looking lashes. Paired with a volumizing mascara, it approaches false-lash worthy. It stays on so well that sometimes it's hard to remove at the end of the day.

This is my favorite mascara ever! It goes on smooth and does not make my lashes look like little twigs like some other brands. I was skeptical at first because the brush seems large to me compared to others I have used, but it separates my lashes nicely. I will definitely buy it again.

This mascara provides a color/length very comparable to other mascaras I've tried, but is easily the winner when it comes to not smudging or flaking. Even after sleeping in it!!! And it is not clumpy at all. It's perfect for the girl that wants to add a ton of length but doesn't want to look like she is wearing too much makeup.

This will be my third time purchasing the full size after receiving the sample in my August box. It has never clumped on my lashes or in the tube as all my previous mascaras did. Thanks, Birchbox, for introducing me to this product.

thank you for publishing the reviews that helped me decided to buy my last mascara brand ever! This is so different from mascara from the smell to texture to lengthening to volume I am just sad I waited so long to buy this. I cannot wait to buy another tube for my sister.

It's a good mascara but It didn't do what I need it to do. Made my eyelashes look fuller but not longer, so they end up looking crazy.

I'm switching mascaras and purchasing this -- my lashes look long and amazing!! Havent smeared or itched either! I sometimes have problems with my contacts but not with this!

When I received the sample in my box, I loved how it made my eye lashes separate and look fuller, so I purchased the full-size. Within a few uses, the gel was thick and was clumping on the brush, which never happened with the sample size. I will not be buying it again.

I guess this mascara might clump if you put on layer after layer of this mascara, but since I only put on about 2 coats, it looked fabulous! I love putting this stuff on because I feel like I'm doing my eyelashes some good!

Love this mascara - everything I hoped it would be! Beware that it takes a while to dry, though... you will be surprised and impressed by how long and dark your lashes are with this stuff, but you need to be careful not to open your eyes wide for about 2 - 3 minutes lest you get little black dots all over your brow bone!