I absolutely love this eye liner. The sample was full size which was awesome. The liner is easy to apply, is a soft liner which goes on smoothly.

great pencil liner! stays put all day and is soft and pretty. goes on well too. i like the sponge tip for blending. wish there were more colors!

I really didn't like this eyeliner. The color was absolutely beautiful but it literally smudged within the first 5 minutes that I had it on. I would not recommend this!

It doesnt apply easily you have to rub so hard its almost as if it doesnt have enough color in it or its empty. I cant figure out whats wrong with it.

It's not going to change your life, but the color is nice and the texture is good. It smudges a little more than I'd like, though.

It went on really smoothly which was my favorite part. I also REALLY liked the fact that the "smudge" end of the pencil wasn't foam. So it won't absorb dirt/the color for an infinite period of time and will remain a good smudging surface.

This is a good liner if you're looking for something quick and easy to smudge. It just didn't tickle me pink for my eyeliner type of preference, but does what it should very well.

I was extremely disappointed when my Laura Geller I-Care Eyeliner arrived broken and melted. Thank you (Birchbox) for your sweetness, email, & willingness to help me out. The color I received was: Caffe Mocha--it was gorgeous! I have brown (almond-shaped) eyes so this shimmery color really made them pop! I'm a contact-wearer & this brand really seems great for sensitive eyes. Also, I'm in love with how great this eyeliner seems to stay (waterproof). I will be purchasing this eyeliner 'elsewhere' because I don't want to have this product shipped to me.

This is a very nice eyeliner. I personally tend to use liquid eyeliner more often, but this went on well and stayed until the end of the day. The brown is a nice dark chocolate. I probably won't purchase since it's kohl, not liquid, but would definitely recommend.

I loved the product, but it was the packaging that got me. The cap snapped so tightly to the plastic that I struggled to pull it back off. When I finally managed to pull the cap off, it nicked off a layer of the eyeliner stick!