This is the perfect liner for a smokey eye. Easy to smudge and stayed in place! Will purchase again. Does it come in brown?

This eyeliner goes on really smooth and stays put for the most part, but I put primer on before, so that helps I'm sure. It's a great color, very dark black. I'd buy it again. . . although I don't feel like it's anything spectacular.

Based on the photos I thought this eyeliner was going to be thicker and well.. more than what I got. The price seems decent compared to other things sold on the site but I feel like a drugstore brand can have the same effect for a cheaper price. The pencil's width is thin, which can be helpful for precision but not so great for creating a cat-eye or smudged smoky look. The product does apply well, however, it's not amazing and I will not be repurchasing it anytime soon.

This eyeliner goes on smooth and stays on all day. I typically use it on my top lid, and it makes my eyes appear bigger.

definitely not a great choice for me... left me with smeary look shortly after application. went on beautifully - but i was looking for eyeliner that stays put

I wish I did not have to sharpen this eyeliner, but it is worth it! It goes on smoothly and stays put all day and through every night shift I work. I have tried hundreds of different liners looking for "the one". This is it!

Disappointed in this eyeliner. Just your average joe. Doesn't glide on and does't last the day either. Disappointed in the quality. Reminded me of a cheap cvs brand eyeliner. The black wasn't even that black.

I really like this liner. It's got a great kohl look, very dark. It doesn't bleed too badly - stays on pretty well throughout the day. Easy to sharpen without breaking off.

This eyeliner goes on smooth and stays all day without smudging. Love it and totally found a new staple in my make-up bag.

The Noir Kohl eyeliner in Black is quite possibly the worst kohl eyeliner I have tried. It blends with some effort and smudges soon after application.