This is the easiest eye liner I've ever put on. Love it! Lasts a long time and looks great! i've been searching for an eyeliner like this for 35 years! Finally!

I accidentally ordered this eyeliner instead of one my daughter suggested to me, however I fell in love with it the first day of use! Love the velvety feel as well as the relief of not having to reapply throughout the day - often, even after washing my face the night before, I'll wake up and think I've forgotten to remove it the night before as it just subtly sits among my bottom lashes very softly. Really a great product to keep in my makeup bag!

I love this product, and was so sad when my sample ran out, so I purchased the full size. It lasts forever and through anything, which I need with such bad allergies right now. I don't have to worry about touch-ups or it running down my face. It stays put and lasts all day.

THIS IS HANDS DOWN MY FAVORITE EYELINER EVER!!!! IT NEVER SMEARS AND IT STAYS PUT. IT LASTS ALL DAY LONG TOO!!!! YOU DON'T NEED TO TOUCH UP. HIGHLY RECOMMEND THIS!!!!

Black is the blackest black! My favorite eyeliner for dressing up dramatic eyes. Wear lasts a long time, and pencil lasts a long time as well.

The eyeliner itself glides on very smoothly. But the pencil is hard to sharpen. Mine might be misshapen because each time I sharpen it, there remains a little side of the pencil where the wood of the pencil sticks out all the way to the tip of the eyeliner. So when I try to apply the eyeliner, I scratch my eye with the wood. I will definitely stick to pencils that have a twist up mechanism from now on.

Cream eye liners always smudge on me for some reason. Oveall loved the rich pigment. Nice when tightlining. No tugging or pulling. It just smudged a little at the end of the day. Definitely no sweatproof with working out.

I have mixed emotions about this. The color is really great, a nice, dark black. I am not sold on the consistency, I have found that it is prone to melt and then run. If you can keep this in a nice dry place, it would definitely be a viable option. On the plus side, it goes on really smoothly and looks nice.

I got this eyeliner in one of my Birchboxes and was happy about it, but I didn't use it right away, because I have several other liners... well, I saved the best for last! This Noir eyeliner is sooo smooth and makes the most beautiful line (either over or under your eye shadow). It wears very well and it doesn't tug or pull at all. I sharpen it with a double-sided Sephora brand sharpener (so, the small end of any sharpener should work ). It's standard size and it's true black. Love, love, love it. And that's a fact :)

On a constant search for the easiest to use eyeliner, this became a quick favorite. I was sold by the long lasting, waterproof and "velvety" description and all of the above were true! I have been a fan since day one! Only downside was the tip broke off the first time I used it, thank goodness for sharpeners!