I'm a huge Stila fan, but didn't think to try their mascara until recently, when I got a sample size one. I'm in love!

I have auburn hair with very pale lashes. My bottom lashes are almost invisible. But this mascara makes them look long, thick, and luxurious without making them look like hair tarantula legs. And it definitely does hold a curl!

Every other mascara I've tried has clumped and flaked off (and I've tried expensive stuff, with and without expensive lash primer.) I thought I was just destined to have yucky lashes forever. But Stila's Forever Your Curl has made me excited to put my mascara on- it's a real transformation! Feels so glamorous :)

This is something I go to again and again. Great texture- not too clumpy, but goes on thick for a nice dramatic lash thickness which is just right for everyday use. I hate to finish a tube and probably try to hold on too it far too long getting more uses out of it lol

This mascara is relatively good and did hold a curl without me having to curl my eyelashes. The main downside for me was that this mascara is not waterproof. Otherwise, I like the color of this mascara and how long it made my lashes.

I find myself to be an extremely picky mascara user. In other words, I tend to get endlessly annoyed at the clumps I find in my mascara. I have tried numerous brands of mascara, only to find myself consistently disappointed. This mascara was one of the better ones. It still contains a few clumps, but they were bearable. Of the other brands I have tried, I give this one four stars.

This was a good thickening mascara, it did hold the curl made from my eyelash curler, much subtler curl otherwise. I did have some undereye smudging with this product towards the end of the day.

Not sure why it's called "forever your curl" - certainly doesn't curl lashes and doesn't do much to coat lashes either.

This is one of the best light weight mascaras I've come across. It does a really good job at separating and lengthening with out giving you spidery lashes. It's pliable enough that you can build up your coats with out clumping, but don't expect a real dramatic eye out of this product. The one thing I didn't like about it was that I found when used on my bottom lashes, within a couple hours I started to get the dreaded black smudge.

If you're into building with multiple mascaras, I found this product acted awesome as a primer. I would do two coats of this to separate and lengthen my lashes, and then 1 coat of a more dramatic mascara over the top. It really gives that fake eyelash effect with out the hassle.

I am VERY picky about mascara and was devastated when my favorite mascara was discontinued. I have been using this now and I'm in love! Gives great volume and length, even for a curling mascara. A must have for mascara snobs!

I liked the mascara. It didn't clump very much, but it didn't stay on for very long. I found it smudging frequently.

Sadly, this is the worst mascara I have ever tried. Mere hours after applying, I inevitably have raccoon eyes for no apparent reason. No sweating, it's the middle of winter so it's not hot outside....it just runs and smudges merely by blinking. How embarrassing to look in the mirror and realize that you've been walking around all day looking like you just got back from a walk of shame after a night of drinking.