Really enjoyed this stick for a short period of time. The sparkle gives your eye a nice little pop of texture. Stays put but after a while it got hard to apply. It didn't apply as easy as I would have liked. Like another reviewer mentioned, be forewarned that if you leave the cap off for whatever reason it dries out. I had to throw mine away after a couple weeks.

Love the pencils, love the colors, have 5 of them and use them all the time. They stay put and last all day.

I have been using the Stila Smudge Sticks for a long time, I have about 10 of them, I'm a big fan. They go on easily and smudge great with a smudge brush. The colors are great, and they stay on. The huge downside is if you leave them open on accident, which tends to happen to me too much, they will completely dry out and become useless. Good thing they aren't too pricey. :)

I have a hard time finding eye liner that doesn't smear off after a few hours or start to run after a few hours at work...this is PREFECT! I'm hooked!

This is, without a doubt, the worst eyeliner I have ever attempted to use. It goes on oily so it doesn't stay put and the one I received did not sharpen so I only got two uses out of it. I usually use Bobbi Brown's gel eyeliner and I will stick with that. It works beautifully. Very disappointing, especially after reading so many great reviews.

No matter what I do, I look ridiculous in black eyeliner. I look like I'm trying too hard. I got the Lionfish sample in my BB and when I wear it, I get compliments on my eyes. Even from my friends who swear by black eyeliner. On its own it stays on for an entire workday. If I want it looking good 'til bed I'll put some eyeshadow primer on my upper lid.

Blendable without being too soft, draws a nice sharp line if desired and sticks around for a while. I lucked out and got the color Purple Tang which looks fantastic with brown eyes.

Goes on easy, stays on throughout the day, but it's not a pain to take off at night. The price is reasonable too.

It is so easy to use, goes on perfect almost every time, and the Lionfish (brown) has a great shimmer that compliments my blue eyes. Couldn't be happier with this!

My biggest problem with pencil eyeliner was it falling when I wore it on my bottom lids. Stills waterproof smudge proof pencil is fantastic! It stays all day great color and washes off easy when your ready. I highly recommend this product. I own every color.