No matter what I do, I look ridiculous in black eyeliner. I look like I'm trying too hard. I got the Lionfish sample in my BB and when I wear it, I get compliments on my eyes. Even from my friends who swear by black eyeliner. On its own it stays on for an entire workday. If I want it looking good 'til bed I'll put some eyeshadow primer on my upper lid.

Blendable without being too soft, draws a nice sharp line if desired and sticks around for a while. I lucked out and got the color Purple Tang which looks fantastic with brown eyes.

Goes on easy, stays on throughout the day, but it's not a pain to take off at night. The price is reasonable too.

It is so easy to use, goes on perfect almost every time, and the Lionfish (brown) has a great shimmer that compliments my blue eyes. Couldn't be happier with this!

My biggest problem with pencil eyeliner was it falling when I wore it on my bottom lids. Stills waterproof smudge proof pencil is fantastic! It stays all day great color and washes off easy when your ready. I highly recommend this product. I own every color.

I loved this product. This was in my first box and has become hands down my most favorite product to date! I love the Lionfish color and I plan on purchasing once my sample is gone.

I've been looking for a liner that does not transfer to my top lid as I get warm. This one is very nice (does transfer just a little) but also washes off with soap and water. Would recommend this for anyone who wants to look good while playing sports.

I bought this in several different colours and have not been disappointed. They glide on smooth and last throughout the day. I like that they are smudgeable but once set- it stays until removed. Only qualm is price...$20 each is a bit much.

I ordered this product in the Stargazer shade. It's basically black with some shimmer to it. It's a nice color, but it is not waterproof as it says. I wore it out this past weekend and within a couple of hours most of it has melted off / smeared around my eyes. It just made my eyes look like a terrible mess. I don't think this product is worth the price.

I received the Lionfish color in my Birchbox, and its a brown color. I love brown eyeliner, but my eyelids developed an allergy to the brown pigment (i can only wear black now), and I haven't been able to find a brown eyeliner that I can wear without my eyelids getting puffy and red, until I tried this one. I love the eyeliner, it goes on very smoothly, and even has a little smarkle in the shade. Plus, my eyelids don't get red/puffy when I wear it. I am so completely happy that I finally have found a brown eyeliner that I can wear. Thank you to Stila!!!