I tried this product because my regular eyeliner was sold out. It worked for the time I had to use it, but was not what I was used to. The brush was kind of hard to use and I feel like there wasn't a ton of product. It smudged kind of easily for me, but I have very watery eyes so I don't know if that had to do with it. On the plus side, it always applied BLACK, it wasn't faded by eye shadow getting on the brush as other products I've used. It dried very fast and doesn't feel wet or heavy when it dries. Also, the packaging was adorable, as it always is with theBalm's products.