First of all, for quite a long time I was using the Vasanti scrub - which is hands down the best exfoliating scrub I've ever used. I decided to try this Yes To scrub because I'm trying to save more money in my life, and there's about a $30 difference in price between these two products. Well, I've decided you get what you pay for. The Yes To Tomatoes scrub is quite watery and therefore I have to use a lot of it in order to feel nice and exfoliated. I like the fresh smell, however, and the packaging allows you to get all the product out of the bottle (which is a problem with the vasanti scrub).