At the risk of sounding like Randy Jackson on American Idol, "It was just alright for me, dog."
Maybe it was my annoyance with the sample bottle and how much effort it took to get a dime size amount of face wash to use.
Maybe it was my aversion for the name Billy.
Maybe it's because I already have an exfoliating cleanser that works just like this one, costs a fraction of the price this goes for, and smells better, too.
I certainly wouldn't disagree with any of the positive reviews, but I also can't see how anybody was impressed enough to give this 5 stars.