This stuff works ok but honestly, baby oil is just as effective.
I take my makeup off before I go to bed, so the oily residue from baby oil really doesn't bother me. I bought this stuff because even with baby oil, there's a little bit of black that runs under my eyes when I rinse off. So I sprung for the $18 (!!!) for this pretty small tube of remover, supposedly designed to melt this stuff off. It works no better than baby oil. Still a little residue when I rinse. Now, I guess I could GLOP ON more of the remover, but at this price, I want to be judicious.
Overall, not worth the money.