These are definitely one of a kind eye shadows. And of course being from one of the most luxurious brands on the market, I had high expectations. I was very pleased for the most part and would recommend this to some, although they are not going to be for everyone. The shadows themselves are of great quality, but because the have a fair amount of sizable glitter, you are going to experience problematic fallout, even when used wet (with MAC Fix+) I experienced this, but far less than when used dry. I honestly could have done without the glitter overall, but I think they should have at the very least made one or two shades glitter free. So that is the main reason I gave it 4 instead of 5 stars, but really fallout is inevitable with a shadow of this nature. The other reason is the packaging, on the top piece the picture and logo is literally a glued on piece of plastic, which is a bit cheap looking. But the actual container is a nice smokey gun metal-ish color and is quite heavy and expensive feeling. Overall I am happy with my purchase and will definitely get use out of it within my collection, but probably more so on special occasions & for more of a "GLAM" look.