I love this makeup remover, mainly because it's one of the only effective natural options I've tried. It removes waterproof mascara and eyeliner with ease. I've been using this product for a little over a year now, and unfortunately I think they've recently changed their formula. While it is still very effective at removing eye makeup, the formula is now a bit more watery, so I have to use more of it to get the same result. But I still love it and have no plans to change brands. Highly recommend.