I wanted to like this mascara, but it just made my lashes stick together and didn't really give any volume.
Works like mascara.
I was very excited when I got this product in. I tried it and it worked like your average mascara would. No pop or wow factor. But it did the job and that's all that matters to me.
Enough with the Mascaras!
Got this as my "full size upgrade" and all I can say is enough with the mascaras! It takes me a few months at least to go through a mascara and since joining BirchBox, I feel like I've gotten enough to last me a decade, especially as my full size upgrades. I am very picky about mascara and while I have liked wha they sent me so far, this one was not great at making my eyelashes look full and it also got all over my eyelid when I applied it for some reason. So will probably very rarely if ever use this mascara again and that seems like a waste of an upgrade to me.
Good formula, not a great brush
I like the formula on this, but the brush is a little sparse for my taste. Made it a bit more difficult to apply evenly.
Clumpy heavy mascara
I am a huge fan of the mascara's that birchbox usually sends me (I'm OBSESSED with Laura Geller's Mascara as well as the Smashbox one I got last month) but this mascara is super clumpy!!! It feels ridiculously heavy on my eyelashes and it simply uncomfortable to wear.