Eyeliner was already dry and mascara was not good for my short, straight lashes
I really wanted this to work out but the eyeliner was already dry when I got it and the mascara was too heavy/wet for my poor, straight lashes. It basically negated the time I spent curling my lashes. I know a lot of folks who love it, and I'm bummed it didn't work for me.
mascara is awesome!
I used to always have problems with my mascara ending up all over my eyes and his has been the first mascara that has not smudged onto my eye and has lasted for most of the day.
Liner -1 / Mascara +1
I really like the mascara: it goes on clean and lasts all day with minimal flaking. The eyeliner could definitely use some improvement. I got this set TWICE because the first time the liner was dry upon arrival. The second time (despite storing it brush down and tightly sealed) the liner dried up within a week. I will not be purchasing this again.
The mascara stayed put until I removed it and went on smooth without the dreaded clumps. The eyeliner is ok but I wasn't impressed.... A fine "marker"... Just not my thing. I did not receive the tool with this purchase, but no biggie, the mascara more than makes up for it. Will definitely purchase this mascara again!
When I first got this sample I was absolutely obsessed with the brilliant idea to put mascara in a squeezable tube. I really enjoyed the length and drama it added to my lashes. Halfway through the full size that I ordered I am no longer a big fan. It's a little crumbly on my face. Who wants little black spots on your face? Not me. Also, it's a real pill to remove and it seems to smudge and smudge even with eye makeup remover. I'll finish the tube and move onto something less bothersome.