I have tried the benefit gimme brow, and I would say that it is more of an "essential" brow item than this. That being said, this product does a good job of adding dimension to your brows. I have lightened my hair, so it's a nice touch to a have a highlight go through my brows to lighten them up without losing definition.
I can see why people feel like this product is unnecessary if you trying to use it on top of another brow product. I agree that it probably wouldn't add much. However, as someone who is very pale with platinum light blonde eyebrows naturally, this is an excellent product for a more natural looking brow! If your brows are sparse, it won't necessarily fill them in, so I usually go in with Precisely, My Brow along the lower edge of my brows where they are patchier, and then I fill in the rest with this. My brows look clean, defined, and natural and it's so easy to use—and fast. I hope they keep making this because it immediately became a staple in my makeup bag. I love this stuff!
I loved this product. I have good eyebrows. But this product make it one easy set to make perfection. It is so easy to use and get best results! It is one my favorites now.
I bought this because as I am getting older my eyebrows are getting more sparse. I have to admit that this product it not my favorite. I will use it until it is gone, but, I will probably not by it again. It really doesn't give me the effect I was looking for and I still have to use a pencil.
I'm not sure what this does?
I bought this thinking it would be a nice tinted brow gel that didn't bulk up my brows as much as Gimmebrow. I don't have a problem with my brows being too thin, but this really does nothing. Maybe if I had lighter, thinner brows this would make sense, but I'm not positive what this product is or what it does or is supposed to do. I will probably do a return.