I love this eyeliner, probably one of the best I've tried other than Chanel's eyeliner. Love wearing the black eyeliner at night or for events because it stays on ALL NIGHT. I bought another color, black shimmer, that I don't think they're selling anymore? But I wear that for an everyday look- a little more subtle than the black. I've found that after you apply it to your eyes, it's best to wipe the brush off so it doesn't get clumpy or hard. Other than that, I'm on my 3rd one so far. They also last a really long time!