I like these products a lot. The fat lip pencil is easy to apply, vibrant, and a really nice shade of red with an orange undertone. The nail polish is also easy to apply. It can be a little globby coming out of the tube (due to the shape), but it is nothing that couldn't be fixed by wiping it off on the sides. It definitely looked like my nails were done professionally - no excess dripping - and a great hue after two coats. It doesn't have the staying power of some other brands, but I don't mind touching up to have it last longer.
The one complaint (and the reason for the four stars) is that these colors are NOT marsala! I was excited to have some products in the Pantone color of the year, but these colors are way more orange than marsala (which is more muddy and brickish). The nail polish especially is a lighter orange/red which is nice, but not as advertised.