I received the magnolia sample in the November box. I had to buy it, it is so gorgeous & the pigment is so rich. I love the square shape of the lipstick for precise application. It feels so luxurious that I can't wait to try other shades.
I really liked the feeling of this lipstick. Application comes out really smooth and creamy. I would prefer it in a different color than the sample I received.
This was broken when i got it in my birchbox. Terrible packaging and sample
I got the magnolia shade. Its a lott pinker than it appears on here. When applied its kind of a weird mix of wanting to be a very pink lipstick and the more "magnolia" one its advertised as. Not really my cup of tea. It goes on very smooth and soft with a matte finish so maybe I'd like a different shade more.
Did not like
The color was pretty good, I liked the little sample size good for carrying in my purse but it does not stay on at all. It came right off...