I received this product as my Birchbox Upgrade for the additional $20 per month, but I feel as if I got a defective sample. My "quad" only had two different colored shadows. I had a shimmery champagne highlight shade and a darker shimmery chocolate brown, both with golden undertones. The pigmentation is not great - you do need to layer on to get the color pay off. There is no fall out - which I was very happy about. The shadows aren't as buttery or creamy as I prefer - a little on the drier side, but that was fine because there was no fall out to clean up after. I don't know if I would every justify spending $16 on this "quad" - maybe if you get the four color and don't mind not having super pigmented shadows and want a more natural look. I think there are better shadow quads out there for the money - but this might be a nice option for others.
love the color pallet, seems like it stays put longer than other brands i've used (especially during the hot sweaty summer months)
i would order again, can't go wrong with Marcelle makeup :)
Very Rich Color and Great Shadows!
This quad allowed for a rich coating of fine powder on my eyelids and gave them shadows and creases as if naturaly sprayed on. I got the nouvuau nude and felt like a model from a safari in africa, after puting it on.
Love the texture and look of this eye shadow. Due to allergies I needed something perfume free. This is the first eye shadow that does not irritate my eyelids. Thank you!
Perfect blends for a natural defined eyes
the neutrals, like Browns and deep shimmers pop our eyes! If you're not afraid to blend? Blend blend blend!
I get more compliments overall with the treasures of BIRCHBOX