First off, I think that you get a lot of bang for your buck with this eyeliner. $11 for something that will most likely last me for a good while since it can be sharpened. However, I am not impressed with the consistency of this eyeliner. It is not very soft, and therefore does not go on very easily or smoothly. I like the color and the price. This was my first purchase for a Marcelle brand product. I would be willing to try their other products, but I will not be purchasing this particular one again.