This eyeliner didn't really look or feel significantly different from other eyeliners I already own, but nonetheless I'm always happy to have another black eyeliner. Not bad for one of the first "all-natural" makeup products I've owned.
This brand in general is amazing. But this is one of the smoothest pencils ever used and I've tried my fair share. So amazing and sharp. Bold lines but in a thin manor. Omg.
It smudges and nothing is good about it except its organic ingredients
I used it once and never again. It has no staying power and was very disappointed. The only thing that was nice about the eyeliner was that it was made of organic products. I wish it had more staying power. :(
If I could give 0 stars, I would...
This is BY FAR the worst eyeliner I have ever purchased from Birchbox. I wanted to give the pencil a try because I am a big believer in all-natural products, but this smudges SO BAD, both on the top of my eyelid and below. I have had raccoon eyes at work before 10AM everyday this week and by the time I go to check in the bathroom mirror, I've already been walking around looking like I let a 5-year-old do my makeup! Wish I would have just ordered the eyeliners I can trust not to smudge like Cynthia Rowley or Noir... very unhappy!
I really love this eyeliner. I like the brand and the product works well too! I have sensitive skin so this is perfect for me!