I bought this for my husband for the holidays. When it arrived one of the viles was broken. Birchbox was wonderful and replaced it immediately so that I would have it in time for the holidays! However, the second box arrived also with a broken vile. Birchbox was ready to send another box but I wouldn't have it in time for the holidays. So, I took a refund. How wonderful Birchbox is with their customer service. I gave the 2 boxes of cologne to my husband. Unfortunately, there was not one fragrance that worked well on him.