So I do like this eyeliner. But I'm tired of dealing with it all over my under eye. It seems to fall on more more than other people and the upkeep is a pain in the butt. I don't know that the eyeliner adds enough benefit to put up with it. All that being said, this eyeliner was good, made a nice clean line, and laid down good color. It didn't stay up any better than other eyeliners, but that's not unusual.