POP Beauty In Liner Customer Reviews

It went on smoothly, made my eyes pop! I just wish it didn't melt so easily ( I live in South Florida) as I ended up with Raccoon eyes by mid-evening. :( . I recommend it for cooler climes, for sure!!

i am not in love but i don't dislike it. It does smudge on my eyelid during the day and looks a little messy, but I've tried worse so i take this as a win. Pretty good not great though. Worth the price.

This eye liner is a staple for me now. The blue shade is the perfect color, not too bright or light. It goes on well and stays well. I use it in lieu of eye shadow for a cool, yet subtle look.

my favorite eye liner. the color is great!! it stays on well and all day!!

I like the blue color. It looked good, but it does not last all day. Also I like to add a fine line to my lower lid, but this pencil is too thick.

In all seriousness, why should you have to sharpen an eye pencil when there are products like this that give the same effect and twist up! I purchased this in the green as an alternative to basic black eyeliner and I love it.

Another quality eyeliner from Birchbox. Fun to use, easy on the eye(Lids) and long lasting. Always enjoys trying something new.

I have been using this eyeliner for years! I have owned all three colors and love the black and the blue. They are very easy to apply and long wearing. This liner is not super pigmented which I like for a natural everyday look. Was very happy to see that Birchbox carries this item!

I love this eye liner. It is everything it says it is and does all it says it'll do. Goes on smoothly and effortlessly. Plus it stays put. I need something that lasts for 10-12 hr days. This does that beautifully.

I like this liner. It is a good consistency and easy to apply. It is difficult to get very sharp so I only wear it when I'm ok with thicker liner. It is not ideal for cat eye or anything fancy like that.