I drew one line to swatch this color and it was a shiny navy blue on the tip before I drew the line, but after, it was just a black liner (under the blue)!! I HATE this brand!! This is the 3rd junk product I have gotten of theirs. I'm tossing anything from Pop Beauty in the trash!
Lip plumper: smells AWFUL!!
Eye Shadow: made my lids red and puffy
This liner: only shiny blue on the outside (under the blue is black liner).