So bummed. I am a faithful user of Eyeko mascara, and I am semi-happy with the Me and My Shadow sticks. A long time ago, Eyeko had fat sticks similar to these, and the consistency slid right off my lids. Fast forward several years: These are beautiful colors, and I was encouraged by some of the reviews. But alas, the pigment has run amok! It's all over my eyes. The colors are great - muted, but with personality. And I used eye primer. Oh yes I did. If you don't care about tossing $15, go for it. Otherwise, put your money toward Eyeko mascara or another kind of eyeshadow that stays put!