Like most other reviewers, my samples were the Suki exfoliate foaming cleanser, the coastal scents eye shadow, and Gilchrist & Soames Spa Therapy body wash. The Suki cleanser is great, but the other items were a yawn---I find it difficult to believe that Birchbox staff are "absolutely wild" about these products! Still, I was reasonably pleased with the cute makeup bag, especially the elastic straps to hold lipstick, etc., in place----until the zipper on the bag broke the third time I opened it!! All in all, really REALLY disappointing, Birchbox! I agree with other reviewers who felt that this should not require a code---it should be offered as a somewhat nicer Mystery Pack for people spending $75 or more. I definitely would not sacrifice a code for this item again.