Create a free account to check out faster, store multiple shipping addresses, view and track your orders in your account, and much more.
Please enter your password to continue.
This longtime favorite has an oversized wand and superdark formula to give you ultra dramatic lashes. The famously big, bodacious brush coats lashes with the ultra-black formula, creating volume and thickness.
Switched away from this after several tubes, tired of having little black smudges around my eyes. In fairness, it was not only this brand, but I finally found one that doesn't cause this problem, and I won't go back to Bad Girls, even if I do like the name. (The one I use now is also carried by Birchbox, of course, Blinc.)4
Within two hours of my day starting, I always have black smudges under my eyes from my mascara. By the end of the day, there's hardly any left on my eyelashes. Not a fan and won't buy again.1
I LOVE this mascara!! It is my absolute favorite! The fluffy brush keeps down clumping and helps make your lashes into a beautiful fan! The formula stays put and only gets better with layers. I but it whenever I have extra cash and don't go to a special even without it!5
I have heard rave reviews about this mascara but I just cannot love it at all. The brush is so big it makes it impossible for lower lashes without having mascara smeared everywhere. The formula is not so great either. Once applied it just made my lashes look wet, not full or lush. I can't justify anything about this mascara especially for the price. I've seen drugstore brands that surpass this mascara any day.1
This is my favorite mascara , it goes on beautifully. There are no clumps and if you want a natural lash look this is the mascara for you. I've actually gone through several of these and I keep buying more!5
I usually love anything from Benefit but I found this mascara to be pretty average. And it dried out quickly which surprised me. I do know many friends who love this mascara though. I just didn't care for it as much. Worth a try though.3
This mascara does not last very long and I didn't notice much a difference after applying. After only a couple of hours it smudges, leaving raccoon eyes. Did not notice any added volume or thickness on my own lashes.2
If I had to use one mascara for the rest of my life, it would be this one! I love the brush and the smooth consistency. It does not clump on your lashes or on the brush at all and a tube usually lasts me about three months, even with two-coat applications and sometimes two applications per day. Definitely one of my tried and true products!5
I've been blessed with long, thick lashes - but have recently started to thin. Bad Gal really gives me the boist I need. I loce this wond. It really separates and thickens my lashes.4
This is the original Benefit mascara. It has a huge brush that I loved once I got used to it. It is dramatic and pretty but did tend to smudge on me.3