Please enter your password to continue.
This longtime favorite has an oversized wand and superdark formula to give you ultra dramatic lashes. The famously big, bodacious brush coats lashes with the ultra-black formula, creating volume and thickness.
I really liked the smooth application and the wand. I also liked that it was easy to remove and didn't need a heavy duty make up remover. My only complaint is I feel like while it lengthens it doesn't thicken as much as I would like, meaning I need to out on several layers3
This mascara comes off too easily. I find myself always wiping it from under my eyes throughout the day bc it rubs off. Pretty disappointing for the price3
This mascara goes on beautifully, but doesn't withstand the day. I'm an active person, and by the end of the day every day this mascara has migrated from my lashes to the skin under my eyes, making me look more tired than I am. I was so excited to receive this mascara because of all the hype surrounding it, but I must say I was disappointed and now only wear it if I'm planning on being out less than 4 hours.
The one saving grace of this mascara is that it never ever clumps.
It seems like this dried out really quickly. I used this every day for weeks and weeks. My lashes looked nice and full without being clumpy. I've used makeup for years and I always close things well to preserve them. I switched to a different mascara for a few weeks and when I came back to BadGal, it was a clumpy mess. I had to toss it out :(3
The end is the best part of this mascara. Used w any other mascara and it would be awesome. The problem I have with the mascara formula is its somewhat light. Doesn't stick to lashes very well.3
This mascara works well, I simply LOVE two of the other mascara products Birchbox sells!! I find the other two lengthen and darken my lashes better.3
My eyelashes looked long and full with this mascara but I didn't get to enjoy the look as it made my eyes water and itch. On the other hand, my sister was happy to take it off my hands and loves it.3
As far as mascaras go, I always thought, the bigger the brush the better. Not in this case. I like Badgal, but it is not worth the price. You'd be better off buying Great Lash. It gets flaky and dries out very fast, so you really don't get your money's worth. This is the only Benefit product that I didn't love. Benefit's They're Real Mascara is a better product and better buy.3
When I splurged on this mascara (I usually use maybelline great lash) I thought it would work better, but it is exactly the same. There are less clumps tho, so I will give it that. I will probably stick with my usual mascara.3
I heard SO many great things about this mascara and had racked up enough points to get $10 off my purchase. I needed a new mascara so after reading all of the great reviews, I decided this was the one. I was let down tremendously! The wand is very fat and I felt so clumsy trying to get it to reach all of my lashes, and the product does not come off the brush easily. It took about 5 minutes per eye just because I kept having to go over my lashes again and again. I used this mascara for about a week before moving on because I wanted to like it- after all, the product does not flake off or smear once on! I love Benefit products but I do not recommend this one.3