Create a free account to check out faster, store multiple shipping addresses, view and track your orders in your account, and much more.
Please enter your password to continue.
This longtime favorite has an oversized wand and superdark formula to give you ultra dramatic lashes. The famously big, bodacious brush coats lashes with the ultra-black formula, creating volume and thickness.
Liked it but had black smudges under my eyes by the afternoon. It also didn't lengthen my lashes like their other mascara "They're Real" does.3
I do really like this mascara, and it does help make the eyelashes look bigger. However, for $19, it seems overpriced to spend on mascara, especially since mascara is used up pretty quickly. You can find a much cheaper option such as the L'Oreal Telescopic which is under $10, and makes your eyelashes look even bigger.3
I really like the brush applicator. The color was great but I did end up with a little faking at the end of long days.3
I really like the application and the brush. However the formula is awful. After an hour I have have flecks of mascara on my cheeks.
I think their other mascara "They're Real" is better.
The brush head is way too large...it makes the mascara messy. If you can manage the size, the mascara is pretty good quality. I just prefer something a little smaller.3
I'm not totally sure why they think a bigger brush and a bigger tube will result in bigger lashes. The mascara is fine, no better or worse than some of my favorites. My qualm with it is the fact that no one, I mean NO ONE, can get through that tube in the suggested vanity shelf life of 3-6 months. Bacterial infestations aside, the mascara dries out well before you're done. I honestly think the oversized brush actually speeds the drying process along. I'd ditch it for Benefit's "They're Real" or another favorite.3
Don't get me wrong, I really love this mascara. It goes on thick and give my lashes that perfect feathery soft look. The brush is easy to use and does exactly what I want it to every time... sadly, every time I use this product, I end up with a funny little black smudge under my eyes after only about an hour. I don't know why it does this, but it takes this mascara from perfect to a dud. Maybe the waterproof formula would work better for me?3
I had high hopes for this mascara because I'm always in search of big bold lashes, but this formula seemed kind of dry. The brush was big and that's why I bought it but it didn't seem to spread the product very well on my lashes. The bristles seemed kind of hard and didn't go in between my lashes well. Will try another brand.3
For the price, I am completely unimpressed. I got this as a sample with a different mascara, and it surely didnt convince me to switch!3
Maybe because I love all the Benefit products I've tried so far (my fave being they're real mascara) but I just didn't think this mascara came close to comparing, maybe the free sample I got was old? Not sure but I wouldn't buy this.3