This longtime favorite has an oversized wand and superdark formula to give you ultra dramatic lashes. The famously big, bodacious brush coats lashes with the ultra-black formula, creating volume and thickness.
This mascara fills in my lashes making them look fuller and longer. It left no clumps and went on very smooth. It stays put all and doesn't wash off easily with soap and water. I needs to use makeup remover to get it all off. My one small complaint I have is the size of the brush. It's great for the longer lashes but a little too fat to get to the smaller lashes in the inside corners of my eyes so I just use the tip for those.
4This goes on nicely, adds great volume, looks fabulous. I would call it a mid-range mascara: better than a lot of drugstore mascaras, but not as amazing as the $28 Diorshow stuff. The one negative I will say is that it doesn't last all day. I put it on before work in the morning and by the time I leave at 5 I look like a raccoon. It flakes off (and sometimes gets in my eyes - not good when you wear contacts!!). I think there is a waterproof version of this product and I haven't tried it but I bet it is perfect--I'm sure the waterproof formula is more likely to stay all day.
4