Please enter your password to continue.
This longtime favorite has an oversized wand and superdark formula to give you ultra dramatic lashes. The famously big, bodacious brush coats lashes with the ultra-black formula, creating volume and thickness.
The formula and wand are great, but this mascara always flakes and leaves dark patches on my lower eyelids! It's very frustrating as it's the only mascara to ever to this on me, and because I do like the nice, natural look it gives my lashes.3
I think I got the dud box cause usually it's great!!! Cover girl would have probably been better.... Sad cause I bought it!3
I received this mascara in a benefit multipack during the holidays and this is the 2nd benefit mascara I have tried and I would say I prefer They're Real. This mascara brush is very large and can be difficult to apply to certain areas. I've noticed that this mascara also tends to transfer on my skin throughout the day. I prefer the volume and lengthening from They're Real over BADgal. But I'm glad I was able to try this since I had been comparing the two for a while.3
This mascara wasn't my favorite compared to benefit's "their real" mascara because this one didn't seem to last as long. Also the brush is More feathery which makes it so not as much mascara gets only you eyelashes. However this isn't a bad mascara! But if I were to choose I would go with benefit's other option.3
I got this mascara with my points. I've used it in the past and really liked it, but for some reason it just doesn't take to my lashes, even after several coats. I love Benefit they're Real much better. I wouldn't buy again. Just not for me.3
I have oily eyelashes so this product ended up underneath my eyes by the end of the day. Benefit's "they're real" stays on better for a comparable price.3
This mascara definitely works, as far as going on smoothly and making your lashes darker. However it did not add as much volume as I like to have with my mascaras. Overall, it is not a bad product, but I lean more towards volume oriented mascaras.3
I was looking for an affordable mascara but wanted to try something different from my usual. This one doesn't give as much volume as I had hoped and if I put it on my bottom lashes, by the end of the day it leaves me with some black underneath my eyes. Probably won't be purchasing again.3
This mascara was clumpy and too thick for me. If you're going for very thick lashes, this might be for you but I like a more natural look for day.3
I liked this mascara because it made my lashes look more dramatic. I was very happy. It had a darker pigment which I liked.3