Create a free account to check out faster, store multiple shipping addresses, view and track your orders in your account, and much more.
Please enter your password to continue.
This longtime favorite has an oversized wand and superdark formula to give you ultra dramatic lashes. The famously big, bodacious brush coats lashes with the ultra-black formula, creating volume and thickness.
I used to LOVE this mascara years ago. It was the only one I used. Then I went to college and was broke so I started using drug store brand (which I love, by the way). I'm 25 now and was feeling like a makeup upgrade so I splurged and bought a bunch of new stuff - including what I thought was my favorite mascara. This is NOT the same. I love the brush - it's still perfect for my lashes. The mascara though... it never used to end up under my eyes. I tried it maybe 7 times and every time I had dark circles under my eyes from the mascara somehow running off. MAYBE the waterproof one would be better ... if you want to try this mascara that would be my advice. I don't like to use waterproof of any brand.. so I'm officially no longer a badgal lover. Really upset that I wasted my money.1
Received this in a Birchbox and loved it. I have received other samples, but this is my favorite. Reminds me I need to reorder..5
I have great makeup wipes and makeup remover BUT BADgal totally defeated them! I applied the mascara and don't get me wrong, it made my lashes look great... the mascara just didn't want to leave my face when I went to wash it off. It seemed oil based and felt like tar on my eyelids as I was trying to remove it - wasn't very pleasant.3
Good but not as good as other benefit mascaras. Definitely not my go to mascara if I want something bold and glam, but it is good enough for everyday wear. And it's a good price3
This is my go-to every day mascara. The brush allows for a full and long application. Mascara is the one must-have before running out the door - even just to the grocery store. Love everything Benefit makes!4
Used my birchbox points and paid the extra and so excited to get it in the mail! Then I put it on.....HORRIBLE coverage. Very sad I wasted my points on this.1
I love everything Benefit and was so excited to try this mascara. Unfortunately it flakes a lot. It pales in comparison to their other mascaras.3
Mascara is my favorite makeup product and I absolutely love this mascara! I really like how this applicator helps separate my lashes as I apply. I wish it would help me deposit a bit more product so I can achieve a more dramatic look, but when I go for that I typically use multiple formulas. This will give you big, natural looking lashes.4
I'm a Benefit fanatic. I used the They're Real mascara and decided to try a volumizing product instead of a lengthening one. HUGE mistake. I assumed that the mascara would be the same quality but provide volume instead of just length. The formula is completely different. Whereas the They're Real formula stays put for 12+ hours, I was shocked to discover that after just 30 minutes I already had black flakes and circles under my eyes. I thought it was just a fluke and reapplied the next day. Same results. Tried it a third time (I'm not a glutton for punishment, but like I said, I'm a Benefit fanatic. They get the "Benefit" of the doubt from me, haha). Same result the third time. I'm giving this product two stars because of the packaging and the wand is excellent quality. Other than that, try their Roller Lash or They're Real mascaras and steer clear of this one.2
Goes on nicely with the bug brush and almost gel like product. But it weighs my lashes down so much I can see them while looking straight forward.2