I'm a Benefit fanatic. I used the They're Real mascara and decided to try a volumizing product instead of a lengthening one. HUGE mistake. I assumed that the mascara would be the same quality but provide volume instead of just length. The formula is completely different. Whereas the They're Real formula stays put for 12+ hours, I was shocked to discover that after just 30 minutes I already had black flakes and circles under my eyes. I thought it was just a fluke and reapplied the next day. Same results. Tried it a third time (I'm not a glutton for punishment, but like I said, I'm a Benefit fanatic. They get the "Benefit" of the doubt from me, haha). Same result the third time. I'm giving this product two stars because of the packaging and the wand is excellent quality. Other than that, try their Roller Lash or They're Real mascaras and steer clear of this one.