I wanted to love this, because I LOVE the Marcelle eye makeup remover pads. Unfortunately, I used this several times with the same outcome. Although it is very gentle for sensitive eyes, it does not remove mascara (even non-waterproof) easily. After several cotton balls, raccoon eyes, and mascara residue left behind,,I had to "clean up" with the last few Marcelle pads.
I will not purchase this again.
I will, however, keep purchasing the pads instead.