Create a free account to check out faster, store multiple shipping addresses, view and track your orders in your account, and much more.
Please enter your password to continue.
Twiggy fans, rejoice: This London-based brand's liquid liner lets you create mod looks in a flash. Rather than frustrating us with a hard-to-control brush tip, it features a pen-style applicator that's completely goofproof, allowing you to control the thickness of the line you create and vary the intensity of your look. Plus, the fade-proof formula will hold up all day and night. Beauty editors adore it too: This liner is a Teen Vogue Beauty Awards winner.
I do my eye makeup daily and found that if I applied it on top of a shimmer or glitter eye shadow, the black was not necessarily impactful/dark. I also didn't like that the felt tip seemed dry while the thicker part of the brush did apply it well. Ultimately, I just prefer a darker black that can stand up to my Smokey eye.1
I am a loyal Stila Stay All Day Liquid Liner kind of gal, but I wanted to try something new. This was highly rated on Birchbox so I gave it a try. I always put my liquid liner on top of shadow, so I expect my liner to still produce a nice, solid line over my shadow. This stuff was dry and only produced a rough, faded line on me. I had a hard time even dragging it evenly across my lash line. I waited a couple more days to try it again, but it still wasn't working for me. I contacted Birchbox for a refund.1
This was like putting a ball point pen on a wet paper towel... So runny that it ran INTO my eyeball... Would not recommend use.1
I did not like this eyeliner at all. It flaked off if I reapplied and it was difficult to make a clean line. Do not recommend.1
I did every trick I knew to get this to stay put, but it was always down my cheeks within an hour if it did not wear completly off by then. I loved the tip and how easy it went on, but it came off just as easy.1
I have received eyeliners almost every month since I've subscribed to Birchbox. I swatched this eyeliner and it seems to work great.1
I tried this and I really wanted to like it but alas no … it did not stay put on me but traveled all around my eyelid as the day wore on thank goodness I was home for morning and all i had to do was remove it and start over with Benefits eyeliner this happened both times I tried it1
This eyeliner is terrible! I have always hated liquid for this reason and refuse to buy it. This specific eyeliner not only stained my contacts to the point where I had to throw away a brand new pair (they're expensive!), but it also left my eyes feeling very itchy and I had a burning sensation. And no, I did not apply it to my bottom lashes, only my top. A line across each eyelid. I will stick to my usual pencil eyeliner from now on and toss this one away. I'm super disappointed.1
I was excited for this liner. It is a beautiful black rich color but it easily smears and is so hard to wash off.1
I was really excited to try this eyeliner so that maybe I could finally perfect my cat eye. When I first got it, I immediately attempted to try it on only to find out that the tip was dry and hardly made a mark on my lid. I sat it upright to let the liquid run down into the tip, then tried it a couple days later. It worked slightly better than before, but was still barely visible. I requested a replacement from birchbox and got it within a few days. The tip was more saturated than the first, but no where near where it should be. I had to press down pretty hard to make a visible line, and still nothing. I found something for a third of the price and it works wonderfully. Would not recommend.1