Normally, I'm a pencil eyeliner kind of girl. I have worn liquid before, but generally choose pencil because I prefer the softer appearance. That said, I own and occasionally use liquid when I am after a more dramatic look.
I've never encountered an issue like I did with this liner. About an hour after I got to work I glanced in the mirror and the eyeliner was bleeding around my eyes. Yuck. Scary! I ended up washing my makeup off and going barefaced for the day. Not interested in trying again. Tossed it!