Mally Beauty Evercolor Automatic Eyeliner Customer Reviews

I got the purple one which does NOT look good, and its not bold or smooth, but dry and difficult to apply

I received the black cherry in a birch box month ago & I was my favorite! I have ordered it many times, but now see it's no longer available! Oh no! It was the best eyeliner I ever used....the color was perfect for me, and it didn't smudge & lasted all day. Please bring it back! Please!

I love the color of this eyeliner. Not super blue but perfectly navy. Exactly as I hope. Went on smooth and easy.

Goes on creamy smooth - no skipping. Navy is a great color. Can make it casual to evening wear with application differences. Wish the price was a bit less.

this product broke off every time I used it but it is still good. the formula is very nice .

I got this sample in a dark blue color. It goes on creamy and is great for smudging if you do it right away... After that, it is waterproof and stays on all day. I also like not having to use a sharpener.

I lovelovelove how skinny this is and the texture - not crumbly, but applies smoothly.

I actually really like this eyeliner, but once I used up my sample and had to buy one, I realized that it's way overpriced.

I really like the color and the texture, so I wanted to keep buying it, but it's just too unreasonable.

I found some eyeliner at the grocery store (Covergirl or something) that works just as well for WAY cheaper.

I love the color of this product, however it was not a favorite of mine. It was hard to apply and didn't go on smoothly at all. :(

I really wanted to like this but I thought it was dry and hard to apply.