Create a free account to check out faster, store multiple shipping addresses, view and track your orders in your account, and much more.
Please enter your password to continue.
Consider this mascara the no-fuss alternative to falsies. It deals lashes a one-two punch, adding both length and volume to keep them looking anything but lackluster. We love how the long-wearing formula doesnt run or smudge, even after a whole day of wear, and gives our lashes a natural-looking curl without weighing them down. The jet-black color makes eyes pop, and its especially great when youre trying to achieve a dramatic night out look. Youll have to convince your friends that youre not sporting faux lashes.
It will take a lot to convert me away from this mascara! It is not too thick, it lengthens lashes well and lasts a long time. The only downside is that it requires makeup remover to wash off entirely.5
Another GREAT mascara from Birchbox. I love the way it adds length, color, volume and sass to me eyes. I will be buying this again!5
Looks great on. Really volumizes and separates lashes. My only complaint is that it is very difficult to remove at the end of the day.4
This has to be my favorite mascara out there! I love the brush, the mascara formula leaves my lashes looking long and beautiful! Love this product and haven't found another one that makes my lashes look longer!5
I just purchased my second tube to this. Before trying this mascara I used BuxomLash Mascara, which I also really like, and I now tend to alternate between these two.
The end of the wand on the Benefit They're Real! mascara is good for getting the lashes at the corner of your eye and this mascara does a good job of not getting clumpy when applied.
I have pretty sparse, stick-straight eyelashes so nothing I've found work miracles for me, but this stuff if pretty good.
This is amazing mascara that works wonderfully on my blonde eyelashes, but sometimes they get too long and rub streaks on my eyebrows. I have deep set eyes, so this happens! Also, the amount in the tube is not very much. It starts being low after only a couple weeks. I can get a good coating by spending more time on my eyelashes, but I really wish there was more in the tube!!4
This is my favorite mascara. Every word in the product description was true for me. Length, volume, and jet black color is perfect for everyday without leaving any dark flakes under my eyes. This mascara will be in my makeup bag forever!5
No, really. It did. And the name of the product is so fitting. Do you guys have any idea how many eyelashes I've lost trying to convince everyone that "they're real?" Everywhere I go people are like, "dude. no way those are real." and I have to pull on them super hard and be like, "see? They're real." It's crazy.5
This is the best mascara. I love They're Real, more than any other mascara I've tried. My only problem is that my eyelashes become so long that sometimes I get little spider legs/black marks under my eyebrow from my eyelashes rubbing up against it. That's the price to pay for having long lashes!4
To me, this is the BEST mascara on the planet! I love it.
Makes the lashes look so pretty- easy to apply and no problem removing it either