Create a free account to check out faster, store multiple shipping addresses, view and track your orders in your account, and much more.
Please enter your password to continue.
For full brows à la Brooke Shields, our wispy arches need a little help. We rely on Sumita’s Brow Pencil, which has a creamy formula that blends in easily to give us the appearance of bold arches. There are three versatile shades that match nearly all hair colors. The light brown Chai is perfect for blondes, while brunettes should reach for Imee, a chocolaty brown. The midnight black Koyla is a match for deeper brunettes and noir hair shades.
As luck would have it I had just changed my hair color the day before my birchbox arrived. This new shade of blue eyeliner is perfect now! It applies smoothly and easily and lasts all day.4
I loved the color but I only could use it one time. Sample didn't have a lot of product inside4
This is a great eyeliner. It's thick and makes very bold lines. The blue is vibrant and gives my eyes something extra. Its not too stick or heavy on my eyes, comes off somewhat easily with some scrubbing but does last all day.4
Like the others, I received the blue eyeliner in my bow, not a brow pencil. A brow pencil like this would probably be fantastic. This eyeliner was not a winner for me. The color looks terrible on me, I found that the product did go on smoothly, but smudged pretty easily. Taking it off was a nightmare though, I had to use two different kinds of eye makeup remover to finally get it off.3
Although I will very rarely wear blue eyeliner, I do think this is a very high quality eyeliner. It glides on very smoothly.4
It seems BB has answered my prayers for non-black eyeliner! Sumita is a great brand and I have been dying for a navy eyeliner. It's not quite as heavy as traditional black for my brown eyes and gives them a pop. On trend and silky smooth application. Only downside is my eyelids are slightly hooded and pretty much ALL eyeliners tend to leave (not-so-)nice smudges and this is no exception.4
1980's middle school me called, she wants her eyeliner back... I realize this is more a critique of Birchbox's decision to send a vibrant blue eyeliner than a review of the actual product, but the fact is, I can't wear it, so I can't make an informed decision about the quality of the product. I will say, it was very difficult to remove when I decided to see how it looked (it looked ridiculous), so I guess it may be long-lasting.3
I got the blue color, and it went on nicely, and I liked the formulation but it was way too blue for me. I felt very conspicuous wearing it during the day, so I'll probably save it for nights out.4
I received a navy eyeliner pencil. Love the color, love the feel. Love the staying power.4
Very smooth, easy to apply and didn't smudge. At first wasn't sure about the color but loved it once I put it on.5