Go from day to night without any worries about smudging or fading with this eyeliner from Love of Color (a Birchbox brand!) eyeliner. Just like our shadow sticks, this pencil comes in a compact, easy-to-tote size and glides on for precision lining (you can also smudge it out for a softer, more dramatic look). And while it's the perfect purse companion, no need to plan on pulling it out of your bag too often—this long-wearing liner lasts up to 11 straight hours (that's from work to dinner and even drinks!).
I use the brown and purple shadow sticks as an eyeliner all the time, so I thought I would love this. It is very black, applies unevenly, and even when sharpened to the thinnest tip possible, bleeds as it applies. It is essentially the same formula as a shadow stick but with no forgiveness. An even line is impossible. I have no idea how this made it through testing. I chucked mine after 2 tries.
1I wasn't expecting much after reading the other reviews but this eyeliner glided on effortlessly and smoothly. Covers like liquid liner without the "mistake" hand shake potential. Lasted all day but was easy to remove with a makeup remover. Overall very impressed and will be purchasing
5