I love the packaging and, while I think it's a bit pricey for what's included, I think it's great for Christmas gifts for the girls or New Years favors.
Here's where I was most disappointed: Birchbox was out of the four pack so I just sucked up the extra $6 and bought four individually (usually BB takes a while to get things back in stock, they are available again now). All four had the same sample: the lip enhancer. And while I'm excited to try this product, I was hoping that to open this with my mom and sister-and-law we would be able to trade and have some fun - so more variety. Nope. Looking online, most of the reviews and videos are for the lip enhancer. I wonder how many actually have the other two products?
I also wonder if by buying the four-pack they thought of this and you get more variety.
So I'm kind of bummed. Might be a better surprise/gift to just buy the lip enhancer for $2 more.