Please enter your password to continue.
Smoky eyes are here to stay. The look is everywhere, from the runway—we loved Clé de Peau’s rose gold take for Vera Wang—to the Oscars’ red carpet, where Amanda Seyfried rocked a lavender smoky eye. This collection, created exclusively for Birchbox, is the perfect kit for creating a subtle but still sultry smoky eye. Each set includes two full-size eye shadows, in Hot Toddy (bronze) and Tiramisu (dark brown), plus a full-size shimmer powder in Firelight (gold).
First, the colors I got didn't match the description. I got no tiramisu. Instead, I got a shade that was actually lighter than the hot toddy so the smokey eye directions are wrong. This stuff is almost pure glitter and sparkle more appeasing to a teenager. A tiny amount sends your eyes into a shimmer like crazy - and you can barely tell the color of the shadow underneath. The price on this makes this a big miss with me. I needed a simple, daytime smokey eye. Since the colors aren't the same, I can't achieve it with the set, but further - it's not subtle... AT ALL.2
All 3 of these ended up looking really nice on my skin. I'm pretty pale with rosey undertones. I like to use the Hot Toddy and Tiramisu to create a more dramatic look. Otherwise I'll use the Hot Toddy for daytime. I use the Firelight as a highlight to my cheeks but have used it on my eyes too. Overall the colors are great and they last a long time. They didn't crease for me on my eyelids which usually happens.5
So this was my first set of eyeshadow that was an all-natural product and I was mostly satisfied with it. I loved the color, I loved that it stayed on while I was applying it (it didn't drip on top of my eyes like some powder eyeshadows will do) and my eyes had a great looked to them after applying this trio. The only reason why I do not give this a 5 stars is that the eyeshadow doesn't stay on for long so you kind of have to reapply. However, I have found this to be the case with most all-natural products so no biggie. I would rather wear this than something that is based on crazy chemicals and things that would damage my skin.4
This a great product from a local company to me in Portland, Oregon. These are great and having been a fan of these for years, happy to see they were on birchbox! These colors are simply beautiful! I am in love with the quality of colors and the little bird design and outer packaging is beautiful! Will definitely re purchase more of this brand!5
I love the colors and the shimmer. But my most favorite thing is that it doesn't make me sick or give me a headache which is hard to do with eye make-up for me. I really love this product all the way around. Thank you !5
The eye shadow I have used every day and I love the sparkle and bling it brings. The shimmer power I save for special occasions and have used it on my daughter for her dance recital. It creates a fabulous sparkle and glow.4
While all of these colors are gorgeous, the pigment is a little to overpowering for my taste. I love a great neutral smoky eye but this is too much. I may try using a natural brush instead of synthetic to see if that changes the application. Like I said, colors are great but they are extremely bold.3
Firstly, I love that these powders are pure and for sensitive skin. I'm definitely thinking about investing in more of Altima pure products once I use up my other products. The hot toddy color is a little too orange for my skin, but tiramisu is a great darker color for when I want to do a smokey eye. I LOVE the shimmer powder for highlighting, it adds a perfect luminescence to add more definition to my face! It's a great little package!4
I bought the set and it makes my eyes look so sexy! Stays on well. Blends well. Really like these eye shadows. Together they are a knockout. Great for the evening but I also us it for day time also.5
This product is fun to use and the colors match my style perfectly. It gives a nice shimmer without being too in your face.4