Stila Cosmetics Stay All Day® Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner Customer Reviews

I’m I don’t want eyeliner it’s not something that I use on a day to day basis. No thanks

My eyeliner had no lid and is completely dried out . I can't try it..
Therefore I gave it a 1..
I would like to have a replacement if possible

I was excited for this product sample as I've always wanted to do a winged eye look. Unfortunately, this is NOT the product for me. All I'm getting is a VERY thin uneven line on my eyelid. I tried using on my lower eye and it just felt too weird during application that I couldn't even finish one eye.

I love Stilla brand, but not a fan of liquid eyeliner. I’m old school. I prefer pencil/crayon eyeliner.

It's a great eyeliner, but I personally already have so many eye liners from Birchbox that it's just going to be added to a box and forgotten about

Dries out really, really fast. Definitely not a fan.

While this review may not hold up to most standards - i'm not a liquid liner kind of girl and it's because of liners like this one. While it was easy to apply and the tip was always full - the liner smeared like crazy! I tried to tap powder over it, let it dry for a ridiculously long time and the liner still continued to smear. If you're not a liquid girl but want to try a liquid liner - I would steer clear of this one.

This is the best liquid eye liner I have ever used. Goes on easy and stays on all day. Love it.

I've heard countless people rave about this eyeliner, so I dropped the money to buy it. My biggest concern was that my eyeliner lasted, and I have to keep looking. This eyeliner fades and smudges even when worn on top of primer with me. I was so disappointed! I'll have to save it for short term wear.

I purchased this eyeliner based on reviews. Lesson learned. Apparently the people using this do not ever sweat or come into contact with anything moist. I can lick my finger and remove this eyeliner. $22 down the drain.