Stila Cosmetics Stay All Day® Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner Customer Reviews

it was such a nice eyeliner and my go to for years. However last year they changed it and its not as matte black or dark. Also very watery now.

The stila Stay All Day liquid eyeliner pen is incredibly easy to use and stays on a lot longer than most liquid liners.

Too much money for an ok product. The tip of the eyeliner stopped working and it's really not waterproof. I was so disappointed. It worked great for about a month which is why I gave it 3 stars and not two.

I must've received a dried out sample because I was unable to get this product to work well on my lids. As far as the packaging aesthetics, I was very excited to try this product because the packing was attractive.

I love how this product glides on. I bought the bronze color and it is so light, but I also purchase the brown. I like dark and dramatic. The bronze color did nothing and the brown was just okay. I did like mixing the bronze with the brown, really cool effect. My biggest complaint was that the product didn't last very long. So love how it glides and stayed but hated it because it went too fast.

I thought I was going to love this...it went on beautifully and the color was perfect! But midway through my day my eyes began to feel sticky, every time I blinked! Once I got myself to a mirror I noticed that the eyeliner was the issue to blame for my sticky lids, I had brown eyeliner all over my upper lids. Mind you I make a small thin line on my upper lids, so I can't figure out why this is happening, I've even tried a primer to keep it from moving!

This porduct looks cute. It Seem amazine...... I would like to try this product maybe one day wear it in my eyes

I love me a good liquid eyeliner. This one stays pretty well and the applicator brush is nice. However, it doesn't go on very thick and I need to apply a couple of coats for it to look right. I have had better from drugstore brands at 1/3 the price.

The color is awesome and the marker shape is perfect. It didn't hold up very well only a couple of uses so you sort of have to work with it.

Got this because everyone was raging about it. Very good eyeliner for beginners. It wasn't as dark as I had hoped after wearing it all day it starts to smudge at the corners and the color fades. Had to keep reapplying throughout the day. Not the worst I've tried but definitely not the best.