Stila Cosmetics Stay All Day® Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner Customer Reviews

Wow! I have wanted to try this product for the longest time. I heard it was one of the best waterproof liquid eyeliner pens. This is not waterproof at all. One of the runniest pens I have ever used. It sucked!

This eyeliner is good when applying to bare, clean face but if you wear foundation, it will not go on over foundation. I tried applying over and over on three separate days, it just won't go on over my makeup. If I try it on my hand, goes on just fine.

Didn't like this product I don't use this product don't need this product

Just spent two hours doing make up, and redoing it about six times. This liner keeps spider webbing out on my eyes before it can dry. HATE It!!!. Now i'll never buy any of their products. Going for "classic Slim line" i look like i'm going to see The Cure. 52 is too old to try to be a goth chic. Not this early on a Sunday anyway..lol

I absolutely love love love this brand & was so excited to see it coming in my box. However, I was disappointed. It did not go on smooth. I won’t be purchasing it.

I’m I don’t want eyeliner it’s not something that I use on a day to day basis. No thanks

My eyeliner had no lid and is completely dried out . I can't try it..
Therefore I gave it a 1..
I would like to have a replacement if possible

I was excited for this product sample as I've always wanted to do a winged eye look. Unfortunately, this is NOT the product for me. All I'm getting is a VERY thin uneven line on my eyelid. I tried using on my lower eye and it just felt too weird during application that I couldn't even finish one eye.

I love Stilla brand, but not a fan of liquid eyeliner. I’m old school. I prefer pencil/crayon eyeliner.

It's a great eyeliner, but I personally already have so many eye liners from Birchbox that it's just going to be added to a box and forgotten about