Sumita Color Contrast Eyeliner Customer Reviews

The sample of this pencil was WONDERFUL! Stayed on all day, went on soft and smooth, never smeared; I had never used a better black eyeliner ~ and I've been using black eyeliner for MANY years! But when I ordered the full-length liner, it became dry and hard within a month, was difficult to sharpen, and finally the color actually fell out of the pencil itself . . . very disappointed, I really wanted this to be the liner of my dreams! Any chance the problem can be fixed?

I don't usually go for any colored eyeliner. I just stick with the classic black, but when I got this in my box I thought what the heck and put it on for a date with my husband. I couldn't tell too much that it was a blue shade, but I loved how easily it went on. Most eyeliners can be quite difficult to apply. The only thing I didn't like was it was difficult to get off completely without scrubbing my eyes. Even then I still had some I just couldn't get off.

I received Sumita Color Contrast Eyeliner in Jaipur Gold, and I thought it was great! I have olive skin and black lashes. This product is a little subtle on my upper lid (aside from the gold shimmer), but it's great for the lower lash line. It's more subtle than black or brown but still defines my eye shape well. And the eyeliner is super smooth in application and doesn't budge!

This didn't knock my socks off and it left me looking like a raccoon after 5 hours - not a fan.

I thought this was a great product until I saw a mirror. It did not stay on and it looked like I had 2 black eyes. Pretty shade a blue but not for my skin type.

This eyeliner goes on relatively smooth and makes a crisp line. Doesn't seem to smudge too much. Quality!

the navy color was not good for my skin tone/ eye color

It was a typical pencil liner. Didn’t love it. Didn’t hate it. Faded completely after 5 hours.

This eyeliner was great. Unlike other ones I’ve used in the past, it stayed where needed to stay and didn’t drip down my face.

The liner was good. I’d love to try more colors! I’ll probably repurchase..